Spicy Jalapeño Margarita recipe (2024)

February 28, 2024March 14, 2024

This Jalapeño Margarita recipe combines the traditional crispness of blanco tequila and the tangy zest of freshly squeezed lime juice with a daring kick of homemade jalapeño simple syrup, offering a spicy yet refreshing drink that’s impossible to resist. This Spicy Margarita recipe is a subtle variation of my dad’s famous classic margarita recipe.

Whether you’re looking to spice up your next gathering, enjoy a vibrant twist on the beloved classic, or simply to explore the thrilling combination of heat and sweet, this Jalapeño Margarita recipe is a perfect option.

Triple Sec or Cointreau introduces a subtle orange undertone that complements the bold flavors, while the jalapeño simple syrup—infused with the spicy essence of fresh jalapeños—offers a customizable heat level to suit any palate. Served it on the rocks, chilled, or frozen.

Table of Contents

So, gather your ingredients, and let’s create a co*cktail that promises to deliver a burst of flavor with every sip. Perfect for any occasion, this Jalapeño margarita recipe is sure to become a staple in your co*cktail repertoire, pleasing both those who love spicy food and those new to the heat.

Cheers to a new twist on an old favorite!

The Ingredients in This Spicy Margarita Recipe

This spicy margarita recipe relies on the following ingredients for its classic, sweet enough but not too sweet, refreshing co*cktail.

• Tequila: Using a high-quality tequila, preferably a blanco for its clean, crisp flavor, will significantly improve the quality of your margarita. Blanco tequila compliments the freshness of the lime and the heat of the jalapeño without overpowering them.
• Freshly Squeezed Lime Juice: Fresh lime juice is crucial for the best taste. Bottled lime juice can be a convenient alternative, but the fresh juice offers a brighter, more vibrant flavor that significantly enhances the co*cktail.
• Jalapeño Simple Syrup: Infusing traditional simple syrup with jalapeño is an easy way to add some heat and flavor to a classic margarita recipe. And, adjusting the amount of jalapeño allows you to control the heat level. Removing the seeds and pith can reduce the heat while still imparting the jalapeño’s flavor. Consider wearing gloves when handling jalapeños to avoid skin irritation.
• Triple Sec or Cointreau: Both are orange-flavored liqueurs, but Cointreau has a higher alcohol content and a smoother, more balanced flavor than most Triple Secs. Choosing between them can depend on personal preference and desired sweetness level.
• Ice: The quality of ice can affect the dilution and overall taste of the margarita. Using large, slow-melting ice cubes is best when serving on the rocks to minimize dilution.
• Limes: To garnish and wipe the rim before dipping in salt.
• Salt: for the rim. Use Himalayan Pink Sea Salt for the pretty color or kosher salt.

Jalapeño Simple Syrup

This super simple to make, Jalapeño Simple Syrup is the key to these spicy jalapeno margaritas.

• Our recipe has you making traditional simple syrup, with equal parts sugar and water.
• Once the sugar is dissolved, add the sliced jalapeno (one jalapeno for mild heat and two for a bit more) and let the mixture simmer for 5 minutes.
• Remove the syrup from the heat and let the jalapenos infuse for an additional 20 minutes.
• Then strain the jalapenos out of the simple syrup.

Tips for Jalapeño Margarita Success

• Simmering the jalapeños in the syrup infuses it with flavor and heat. The longer you let the jalapeños steep after turning off the heat, the more pronounced the flavor and heat will be.
• The white, spongy part of the jalapeño called the pithis where the jalapeño is the spiciest. If you are looking for flavor but not heat then remove the pith and seeds first. The seeds will have some residual capsaicin (the heat)on them which adds to the heat as well.
• The syrup is not overly spicy. Keep in mind the spice that is there will get diluted by the margarita mix so it becomes a subtle heat once in your margarita mix. If you are looking for extra heat, muddle some fresh jalapeños into your margarita just before serving and strain, or use hotter peppers to infuse into the original syrup like serrano peppers instead. Serrano peppers are 5 times hotter than the jalapeño.
• Consider wearing gloves when handling jalapeños to avoid skin irritation.
• Straining the jalapeño simple syrup mixture through a fine mesh sieve is crucial to remove all the solid parts, leaving a smooth syrup that blends well into the co*cktail.
• Chilling the glasses beforehand can add an extra refreshing touch to the served margaritas. For an aesthetic and flavorful boost, consider adding a small slice of jalapeño, a grating of lime zest, or a lime wheel as garnish alongside the traditional lime wedge.
• Taste your margarita mix before serving. Depending on your ingredients’ freshness and quality, you may need to adjust the lime juice or simple syrup to achieve the perfect balance of sweet, sour, and spicy.
• When making a pitcher, gently stir the mixture to ensure the flavors are well blended without overly diluting the co*cktail. Adding ice to the glasses instead of the pitcher will keep the margaritas from becoming too watered down over time.

Agave Nectar or Simple Syrup

I’m a traditionalist with this recipe; I make it how my dad made it and he used simple syrup.

That said, you can substitute agave nectar for simple syrup in the Jalapeño Margarita recipe, and it’s a fantastic idea for a few reasons. Agave nectar is a natural sweetener derived from the agave plant, which is also the source of tequila, making it a harmonious choice for tequila-based co*cktails.

Keep in mind that while agave nectar is a great substitute, it will slightly alter the taste profile of the drink. The result will be a spicyJalapeño margarita that’s likely a bit smoother and might have a deeper sweetness compared to the bright sweetness of simple syrup.

You can still infuse the agave nectar with jalapeño to maintain the spicy element of the drink. Gently warm the agave nectar (do not boil, as it can become too thick or alter the flavor) and add the sliced jalapeños. Let them steep until the desired level of heat is reached, then remove the jalapeños and allow the mixture to cool before using it in your margarita.

Substitution Ratio

Agave nectar is sweeter than simple syrup, so you’ll want to use it in a smaller quantity. A general guideline is to use about 2/3 to 3/4 of the amount of simple syrup called for in the recipe. Start with less, as you can always add more to taste.

Bookmark this page or pin the following image to refer back to this Jalapeno Margarita Recipe in the future.